Hard of Hearing: The Long Good-bye

FEBRUARY 1 will be a big day in Phoenix. The Super Bowl? Nah. Baseball’s arbitration hearings will kick off that day and, though small in number relative to the long list of players eligible for arbitration, the process profoundly impacts the game.

Ever wonder why it’s called a “hearing”? I think it’s because the player sitting in that room can’t believe what he’s hearing. His game is ripped apart by club reps out to convince the three arbitrators that he only deserves the team offer, not his request. It’s not a place for the thin-skinned and insecure.
After a few hours on that rack, most players can’t wait to flee to another place where they can feel more appreciated. Nothing like free agency to turn on the love, as suitors talk their ears off. Of the 14 players who have had to go through a hearing the last four years and eventually reached free agency, 13 abandoned the team that had to testify against him — win or lose.The ony exception, Oliver Perez, seems to be fighting against re-signing with the Mets, over whom he actually scored a hearing decision a year ago.
ryanhoward.jpgClubs do realize the stakes, a lesson that took a while to learn. Nowadays, hearings run about 5-7 a year. Through the first two decades of a process that began in 1974, there were typically dozens of hearings every year, peaking with 35 in 1986.
RYAN HOWARD is the Donald Trump of the current arbitration group, with his $18 million request. For the reasons cited above, I expect the Phillies to be very eager to avoid another hearing with him. For one thing, the club’s $14 million offer sets up a perfect midpoint for a compromise agreement. For another, the Phils learned in losing their 2008 hearing to Howard that their one argument — his record strikeout numbers — has no weight in this era. Not with nine of the top 14 all-time single-season strikeout totals having come since 2000.
KANSAS STATE: I hereby nominate the Wildcats as the official college basketball team of MLB. Most of the time, the guys on the floor are Colon (Luis), Sutton (Dominique), Kent (Darren), Samuel (Jamar) and Clemente (Denis). … 
JEFF KENT: I’ll miss seeing him, both on the field and in the clubhouse. He was a genuine throwback. He’ll now have the time to perfect those wheelies on his motorcycle.
JAY MCGWIRE: Gee, I guess we now get why he’s estranged from brother Mark. 


  1. phillies_phollowers

    Hey, welcome to MLBlogs! As for Howard, I really do think they should consider K’s. Anytime a player does NOT make contact with the ball, NOTHING good can happen. At least if they hit it, there is a chance. Now calculate the % of chances Howard blows by whiffing, especially when compared to other players on the team, and that should translate monetarily in some form. And certainly when deciding on such hefty salaries, it should have meaning. Now, I love Ryan Howard and fully understand the value of 48 home runs, but like I said, with all the lack of contact, I think 18 million is really pushing it.


  2. bostonredsoxgirl46

    Welcome to MLBlogs! Mark recommended that we check you out, and I’m glad that he did. There are so many pros and cons to the whole arbitration process but trying to make some of your star players look terrible IS terrible. But then again, some of the players think they need to be paid much higher than they actually deserve.
    Seeing Jeff Kent’s retirement speech on ‘MLB Network’ made me tear up a little bit. He seemed like such a nice guy, and I think he’ll go to the HOF.

  3. tom_s

    Thanks for the welcome, guys.
    Burgh Blues is cool (though I loved the sleeveless jerseys; they had that retro ’60s look).
    Hey Julie: I think all the FAs who rejected arb regret it now; looks like most of them will wind up signing for much less than they would’ve gotten even as arb losers!)
    Elizabeth, so much for “there is no crying in baseball,” huh? I guess there are plenty of tears AFTER baseball.
    Catch you all later …

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s